It
may seem as if I plagiarized this title when looking at my works cited, but I
literally searched those exact terms for our previous assignment and came
across a SLJ article of identical title. And the reason I was investigating
this topic was because this module has really got me thinking if print
reference work is slowly on it's way to extinction. As I read through each
module for this theme and examined the various formats, atlases, dictionaries,
handbooks, encyclopedias etc. I began to think how infrequently I purchased
these items for our library, and on a bigger scale how outside of my profession
I never used physical copies of them ever. And who actually does? If I want to
plan a trip I don't go purchase the Lonely Planet book like I did in 2000, I
use trip advisor. If I don't know what a word means I look it up on my
dictionary app. Why would anyone consult a 2 year old anything when they could
find more current information online? So I revisited my first blog theme where
I know I discussed print vs. digital and while I still somewhat agree, children
do benefit in a variety of ways from tangible, material reference work, if they
are never used in adulthood will they become less and less available until they
are non-existent?
In
the SLJ article also entitled, "What is the Future of Reference,"
(Verma) some points were discussed that I had not considered before. One,
that physical resources are an equalizer. Even within our own school let alone
in the bigger picture, many people, both kids and adults, still do not have
personal access to the Internet. And two, that physical copies have shelf life.
Albeit maybe a short one, but World Book VP Jon Gregory makes a good point in
the article, "When some administrators and librarians have decided to back
off print reference and buy online products, four or five years later, budgets
are cut and they can no longer buy the online resource. If they had bought
print, they’d have some shelf life. You have zero shelf life with 100 percent
digital; when it’s cut off, you’ve got 100 percent of nothing" (Verma).
I guess it's a question that only time will tell, but hopefully this infographic of an American Forbes study is telling, that when it comes to reading perhaps there is a certain unknown factor or aesthetic, that makes us want to turn pages.
In the meantime, I'll keep
shopping for those big books with beautiful pictures, that kids sit in groups
to pour over, hoping that the day they're forced to huddle around a screen
never comes!
Works Cited
Riedling, Ann Marlow, et al. Reference Skills for the School Librarian:
Tools and Tips.3rd
ed., California, 2013.
Verma, Henrietta. “What Is the Future
of Reference?” School Library Journal,
22 Nov. 2013, www.slj.com/2012/06/industry-news/what-is-the-future-of-reference/.


A good reminder and reflection on the key themes and new learning in our final theme of the class. Your discussion and comparison to your first blog post was insightful and provides some perspective and more importantly, cautions before we go head-first off into an entirely digital future. Your reminders about equality and also tangibility are important, just as your realizations about your own choices and reality of access to current up to date references. A very personalized and insightful look back on our whole course and the big take-aways.
ReplyDelete